Sell Gold, Precious Stones, Jewelry & Diamonds Columbus, Ohio
Pickerington Has Re-Opened! Pickerington Has Re-Opened! Pickerington, we are back in your neighborhood! Our newly remodeled store is ready to buy your unwanted treasures and sell you the best quality coins and jewelry.
Call 793-GOLD (4653)! Call us today for more information, or scroll down to see a clickable list of our locations! Call 793-GOLD (4653)!
Go To Who You Trust Go To Who You Trust We have such a high rating with the BBB for a reason. There's nothing we won't explain, including why you're getting the offer you're getting.
True Customer Service Sit back, enjoy a cup of coffee and let us do the work. The process is quick, simple AND fun. True Customer Service

How It Works

  • Bring in your gold, silver, platinum, diamonds and coins. No appointment necessary.
  • Relax with a free cup of your favorite coffee or glass of water while we sort through your pieces. They will never leave your sight. There are no back rooms and no hidden tests.
  • Based on the current market price of precious metals, coins and diamonds, we will make you an offer.
  • Although we are constantly ensuring that our prices are the highest in the market, a competitor will occasionally run a special promotion. If you’ve received a higher offer for the precious metal value of your pieces, bring it to us in writing and we will beat it. Guaranteed.

Where Are We Located?

Looking for somewhere in your neighborhood to sell your gold, silver and other precious items? We have nine convenient locations throughout the Columbus Metropolitan Area. Search for the one closest to you and click for more info!


0 results have been found

What We Buy and Sell

Turn Gold into cash in Columbus, Ohio

  • Solid Gold Jewelry & Watches (8K-24K)
  • Gold Filled Jewelry
  • Coins (Gold, Silver, and Collectable)
  • Collectable Paper Currency
  • Silver Jewelry & Flatware
  • Diamonds of All Sizes
  • Platinum (including jewelry and wire)


Did you know that we sell now too?


We are selling out of our stores now! You can expect the same competitive prices and top notch customer service when you buy your coins, jewelry, and gold/silver investments from us! Call ahead for details on what each store has available for you.



Steve was so polite and so informative. It truly was a learning experience!

Jennifer from Dublin

I was amazed by how much my old dusty jewelry was worth to Buckeye Gold. Very fair and knowledgeable.

Madison from Upper Arlington

More Testimonals

Questions? Comments? Testimonials?

Please don’t hesitate to send us an email!